Packing Cubes Comparison Overview

If you’re here, that means I don’t think you need any help with “What Is A Packing Cube”. If you do, head on over to my previous article here: Packing Cubes For Travel. That will give you all the background you need and help you begin your journey.

For this one, we’re going to cover various types, styles, and shapes (which can be as varied as the colors). For each area of description, I’ll also mention the particular brands that I have on hand and how they fit into each of these categories. I figure that will cover a good amount of theory and practice as we go through this. Deal? Deal.

So what else are we looking at? From a feature perspective, there are three main features: weight, materials/build quality, and functionality (compression, clean/dry, etc.). They vary heavily across brands, and the ones I have here are no different. We’ll see the spectrum firsthand. 

Some of these also have a few not-so-common features, too. I’ll be sure to highlight those in case they are the differentiators you’re looking for. Let’s dive in.

Brands I’m using in the discussion: Eagle Creek (The OGs), Patagonia Black Hole, Thule, and Peak Design (a boutique darling in the online packing cube discussions).

Also the reason I’m not showing these packed or in a bag - is because unless you pack the same thing as me and use the same bag as me, your setup will look completely different. This is just to get you an overview of the cubes themselves. How we all utilize them will vary.

Features: Packing Cube Size/Style/Weight

Let’s start off with style, size, and weight. I’m going to lump this all into one. Of all features, these are probably going to be the biggest deciding factors for you from when you start to when you finish your evaluations. Packing cubes are ALL OVER THE PLACE when it comes to these so I think it’s also the biggest pain point for the indecisive types. Do I need them to be extra durable (which adds weight)?. Do I need them to be ultralight (which hurts durability)? Do I need them to be purple (maybe)? You get the picture here. The one thing I wouldn’t get too hung up on: What packing cubes should I get for XYZ bag? This might be controversial to some but I really, REALLY don’t think you should spend much time on this unless you just want to get the same brand packing cube as your bag. This isn’t to say there won’t be some scenario on some bag where a certain type of cubes won’t work that well (How’s that for a caveat, you Internet Gotcha Police). But I think it’s just going to drive you nuts. I’ve got cubes from all sorts of brands and never had a real issue. The Bagtris (Bag Tertris, get it? I’ll show myself the door…) is part of the fun.

From a size and shape perspective, I don’t really care as I just work with what I have. I typically go for the variety packs which gives me options. That’s all I want really - options. What I tend to NOT want - are the large sizes. These might be good for bigger suitcases but we’re focused on Onebag Travel here - so those might as well not exist in my world. They can be wider than the backpacks many of us use, so that’s the only time it might matter. I also think the larger sizes work for those that just want one packing cube - but in that case I kind of think that’s what my bag is, no? I want the packing cubes to segment WITHIN my bag. Most brands have various sizes, and I think Eagle Creek does the best with an overall variety of sizes and shapes. So, pick out individual cubes in a variety of sizes that intrigue you, or look for the variety packs to get them all at once.

The grouping I have really does run the gamut here. The Eagle Creek cubes that I own come from their old Specter line and are wicked lightweight in material. The Gonex Cubes are a little heavier. Then, the Thule goes from there as I think they are a 100D. Peak Design is probably inline with the Thule, though maybe one notch below. The Patagonia are by FAR the heaviest and beefiest but what can I say - I love their materials and colorways.

For build quality, Gonex might feel the cheapest but by no means does that mean actually cheap quality. I think the value is there for what you pay and what you get.

Lightest: Eagle Creek

Size Variety: Eagle Creek

Best balance of build and weight: Thule

Most durable: Patagonia by a landslide.

Oddest and Maybe Inconvenient Shapes: Patagonia

Features: Packing Cubes Functionality

Last up are the features you are going to want to think about. I know packing cubes are supposed to be a simple thing, but humans wouldn’t be humans if they didn’t iterate and increase the complexity of a successful said thing. If you just want a box or a tube shaped piece of fabric with a zipper, then you’re more Zen than many and you can skip this section. Look to Amazon Basics in that case. Or Ikea. Or eBags. Or Gonex (I have quite a few of these and they are a great budget option).

The first big one is compression. Many cubes out there offer compression. In my grouping here alone 4 of the 6 do: Eagle Creek Specter, Peak Design, Thule, Gonex. Essentially this is exactly what it sounds like. You can load up the cube with a compression zipper unzipped, then zip it up to decrease the space used by the package overall. Two things to note here. One, this is not a world beater. Don’t expect miracles, but it does help. I look at it more as a preventative measure. I leave them in compressed form so I can’t take more stuff. That leads to the second point - it can mean you stuff more clothes in than you should. Don’t. Pack smarter, not more.

The next major feature that is very, very common is the ol’ “clean/dirty” configuration. What this means is that they are meant to be used with one side only having your clean clothes in it, then you can begin storing your dirty clothes on that other side as you go. It’s a neat idea and really can help you stay better organized. We can all skip the part where we pull out a pair of socks and need to remember if we wore them already… Consider that problem solved. None of the cubes I’m featuring here have this particular feature in mind specifically, though I do have a set of off-off brand cubes that have it. I’ve never really taken advantage of it though because I never ended up using that set much (bought right as the pandemic hit). You could always use a spare small packing cube for this, too. So, some people might not prefer the built-in version. The Patagonia cubes, being clamshell w/internal dividers, could be used in this way, too. The Peak Design incorporates this as well - all in the same inside compartment. But I wouldn’t call those two the specific “clean/dirty/ cubes.

Compression Winner: Thule

Most Features in One Cube: Peak Design

Most Feature Choices In a Product Line: Eagle Creek

Features: Bonus Packing Cube Design Additions

Next up I did want to make sure I covered some more niche abilities that these cubes can offer. Most of them are just “cool to have” and I think the designers had some fun with them. I really appreciate that kind of thing. To be clear I DO find them useful - if not entirely NECESSARY. Those are two very different things in my mind as a traveler. This isn’t a ranking, per se. More of a collection of notable features you might come across beyond the two biggies mentioned above.

Internal organization. The Patagonia cubes for instance have a two-sided design inside, complete with mesh, zippered dividers. It’s really something. For one it works well to pack both sides and get a two-for-one cube, but also you can use it in a clean/dirty way. Nice. Further, it provides more chances for them to use their wild color schemes which I love. Sue me.

Antimicrobial. The newest Isolates from Eagle Creek are actually treated with an antimicrobial element to help fight odors. Remains to be seen if this helps your clothes from smelling, or just the packing cubes themselves. But I like the effort here.

Features from the future. These are exclusively on the Peak Designs as far as I can tell. But, they are super cool. One, is a pull tab design on one of the zippers that lets you get into the bag in one pulling motion based on a U shape set up. Both zippers just magically scoot down their tracks and it’s open. Very cool. Second, the design wizards over at Peak Design came up with some wild, self-healing fabric for the cubes. Yes you heard me correctly. Self healing. I have ZERO idea how this works but the fabric will heal itself with tiny punctures and what not, so those tiny ones do not become big ones. Let’s be reasonable here though it’s not the T1000 from Terminator 2 and will not mold back together if you rip it apart. OR willllll it? No, no it won’t. Don’t do that. 

The Bad Things About These Packing Cubes

There are always some issues to think about with packing cubes. I’ll mention some overall issues but also some issues with the ones I have on hand here since that’s the main focus of this article.

For some - packing cubes are solving a problem that didn’t exist. For SOME. Not everyone likes to be super organized nor do they like to spend that much time placing all their clothes into specific containers. Their bag is their container. Fair. I love them, however. Compartmentalization is my friend. BFF even.

With the groupings I have here - the biggest downside is that a couple are bulky (the Patagonia especially) and on another front they can be a little higher priced if you stick with the more boutique brands (Thule, Peak Design, Patagonia). If you need to buy a few, it adds up quickly.

For this pricing reason - I tend to always lean towards recommending something from Eagle Creek. They are pretty much the original packing cubes company (give or take, certainly they were the ones that popularized them), they have variety packs so you can get a good mix of sizes, they have an overall huge selection of specialized ones as well, and frankly they are pretty reasonably priced. I tend to be more of a “spend on the bag, not the cubes” person and I’ll stand by that view here. But as noted earlier, I’ve had my Eagle Creek cubes for nearly 9 years.

I would consider the Patagonia’s to be pretty niche in terms of people really needing them. Unless you need some super rugged ones or you just really like them due to their build, colorways, and brand - they are probably pretty over the top for most people. Just due to their pricing and bulk. The shapes aren’t that well thought out either and maybe they are better for duffel bags. Again though, I do love them and they are kind of a guilty gear pleasure for me.

(Hot tip - If you are an Amex Platinum card holder, there is a twice yearly Saks 5th Avenue credit of 50.00, and Saks carries the Thule packing cubes online. Who doesn’t love a nearly free two pack of a well made packing cube?)